Community listing

Whidbey Island Seafood Company

21 reviews .
3.1
Restaurants & Bars
Open for claim

Business Overview

Core company details visible to potential customers.

Restaurants & Bars https://whidbeyseafoods.com/

Customer Reviews

Filter feedback by rating to isolate strongest and weakest experiences.

Margaret Holloway
Seattle, Washington, USA

I've been ordering from Whidbey Island Seafood Company for about six months now and the quality is consistently outstanding. Last week I ordered their Dungeness crab and Pacific salmon fillet and both arrived perfectly packed in dry ice, still ice cold. The salmon had that beautiful bright orange color you only get from truly fresh fish. Will absolutely keep ordering from them.

Online Food Ordering Service Jun 19, 2026
Tom Vasquez
Portland, Oregon, USA

As a restaurant owner I'm very picky about my seafood suppliers. Whidbey Island Seafood has been supplying my kitchen for almost a year and I have zero complaints. The consistency in quality is what sets them apart. Every shipment of halibut and oysters arrives fresh, properly labeled, and right on schedule. My customers notice the difference and so does my chef.

Food Products Supplier Feb 14, 2026
Linda Carmichael
Boise, Idaho, USA

Honestly wasn't sure about ordering seafood online and having it shipped to Idaho, but Whidbey Island Seafood changed my mind. The smoked salmon gift box I ordered for my husband's birthday was incredible. Packaging was secure and the product tasted like it came straight off the boat. Knocked off one star only because shipping took a day longer than estimated, but the quality made up for it.

Online Food Ordering Service Jan 28, 2026
Derek Fountain
San Francisco, California, USA

These guys are the real deal. I grew up in the Pacific Northwest and moved to California years ago missing good seafood. Whidbey Island delivers that authentic taste I remember. Ordered geoduck clams and razor clams last month and they were perfect. The website was easy to navigate and checkout was smooth. Delivery came with clear instructions on how to store and prepare everything.

Online Food Ordering Service Aug 17, 2025
Patricia Odom
Denver, Colorado, USA

Really impressed with the variety on their website. I ordered the seafood sampler box for a dinner party and my guests were blown away. The oysters were briny and fresh, the shrimp were plump, and the crab legs were meaty. Customer service was also very responsive when I had a question about delivery timing. Would definitely recommend to friends who love quality seafood.

Online Food Ordering Service Apr 28, 2025
James Whitfield
Austin, Texas, USA

Best seafood I've ever had shipped to my door, hands down. Living in Texas, finding quality Pacific Northwest seafood is nearly impossible locally. Whidbey Island Seafood fills that gap perfectly. Their wild king salmon is extraordinary. I ordered two pounds and pan seared it with just butter and lemon and it was restaurant quality. The ice packing was excellent and nothing was even slightly thawed.

Online Food Ordering Service Mar 7, 2025
Anita Brewer
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA

We've been using Whidbey Island as a supplier for our specialty grocery store for about four months. The product quality is genuinely excellent and our customers have responded really well to the Pacific Northwest branding. Communication with their sales team is professional and they accommodate our order volume well. Minor hiccup with one invoice but it was corrected within a day.

Food Products Supplier Dec 19, 2024
Carlos Mendez
Phoenix, Arizona, USA

Sent a smoked salmon package to my parents as a holiday gift and they called me immediately after opening it to say how amazing it was. The presentation was beautiful and the smoked salmon itself was rich and perfectly seasoned. Whidbey Island clearly takes pride in their product. Will definitely be ordering holiday gifts from them again this year.

Online Food Ordering Service Jul 21, 2024